top of page

From Hillsborough to Manchester: The aftercare survivors still fight for

Fiona-May Swanson
Apr 23
5 min read

Updated: Apr 30


The Hillsborough Support Alliance, Image provided by Barry Cubbins
The Hillsborough Support Alliance, Image provided by Barry Cubbins

“As well as the bombing, we had to deal with the sights we saw that night and people physically jumping or falling from the tiers due to panic and distress. All these years later, I avoid speaking about it” says Emma, one of the many people affected by the Manchester Arena attack.  


The 7/7 London bombings, the Hillsborough disaster, the Manchester Arena attack, where are these people - the victims that were directly involved or those who witnessed the traumatic events?  


Once these events have occurred, the victims are left to return to their normal lives and aftercare measures are put into place. However, what do these aftercare measures actually look like, and are they enough? Events like these leave regular people fearing life, seeing dead bodies and injury while also having to deal with press intrusion and lives being changed. 


A stark example is the Manchester Arena attack on 22 May 2017. A bomb was detonated as people were leaving a performance by singer Ariana Grande. 22 people including several children were killed, with 116 injured and many more left psychologically and emotionally traumatised.  





Following the bombing, bereaved families were supported by Greater Manchester Police, while Manchester City Council provided care and support plans. The Resilience Hub was also set up to provide health and emotional support. However, Emma’s and many others experience highlight significant gaps in this aftercare support.  


Emma Blackburn had just turned 18 when she was involved in the Manchester Arena attack and the last time she was ever contacted was two weeks after the bombing . Emma said: "I believe mostly they didn't know what to do with us because of how many young people were involved.” 


“It was essentially made out to us that if you absolutely needed therapy and you were so traumatised you couldn't cope, you could have it. But that just made everyone feel like they shouldn’t take it away from anyone that lost a friend.” 


Emma experienced symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, including sleep disruption and nightmares. She said: “I think I'd have also benefited from some follow up check ins. It would have been nice to not feel forgotten about." 


Emma returned a year later to the Manchester Arena and did not have her bag or body scanned, causing her to feel as though nothing had changed. 


"Due to this lack of compassion, we received at the time, I don’t think I'll ever truly be able to acknowledge the anger and the fear I felt that day and every day since.” 


A Benefit One Love Manchester concert was held two weeks after the bombing to raise money for the victims. During the concert Emma described how: “They let a lot of paid ticket holders into the standing area, designed for the victims of the bombing to not feel crowded, just to make it look fuller on TV. It really put into perspective that they’d forgotten already what we had just dealt with.” 


Amanda Coleman, a specialist in crisis communication, and the Head of Communications for Greater Manchester Police when the Manchester Arena attack occurred said: “Aftercare following these incidents is essential, I can say as a member of the police we got offered counselling and support in the aftermath of the Manchester Arena attack, but it doesn't happen for the people who need it most, the people who have survived it or have lived through something.” 


“There was not adequate aftercare following these traumatic events, definitely not around Hillsborough because of the lack of candour and the information being manipulated. For the Arena perspective, there was a recognition, but was it enough? I do not think so, especially when you start to look at some of the young people affected. “ 


Similarly, there was criticism from survivors of the Hillsborough disaster that there was insufficient aftercare, with the victims blamed for the event, rather than supported. The Hillsborough disaster was a fatal crowd crush that occurred on April 15, 1989, during a FA cup semi-final between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest. 97 died, along with hundreds injured. The lack of support provided to the survivors led to the Hillsborough Support Alliance (HSA), which is a support group to provide support for those affected by the disaster. 


Barry Cubbins, 77, a survivor and the director of the HSA described how he and others coped in the years following the disaster: “I didn't tell my wife about it, didn't mention it to the kids”. We just sort of bottled it up.” This lack of communication had lasting consequences, affecting relationships, mental health, and family life. 


Barry recalled a moment with his daughters that brought his attention to how he needed to change: “My eldest daughter said to my younger daughter, ‘you didn't see my dad before Hillsborough, did you? He was really funny and used to do all sorts of things with us’” Like many others, Barry had withdrawn emotionally, unable to process or articulate his trauma. 

The Hillsborough Support Alliance, Image provided by Barry
The Hillsborough Support Alliance, Image provided by Barry

Hillsborough did not end with only 97 deaths, with the number of suicides following not being recorded, but noted as ‘many’. Reports in 2022 indicated that at least two more survivors took their own lives after being ‘retriggered’ by the chaotic events at the Champions League final in Paris. One survivor also described how he travelled with a group of 13 people to the match together, and six of those have committed suicide since. 


“We know a lot of people who committed suicide after it.” says Barry. “There was one guy, he took all his money out, something like £50,000, donated it to Hillsborough families and then killed himself.”  


He says the HSA fills a hole the authorities can’t or won’t. “We have a few people in the group that haven't had the therapy, I think there's still the idea that men are macho and don't do this type of thing. I was the same, but when I saw the difference in the people that had had it, I said put me down for it, and haven't looked back since.” 


The organisation is now recognised by the club and has a stand in the club bar. Barry said; “I had two people recently who came in and were a right mess. One has finished therapy now and is fine, the other has joined our meetings and is in a lot better place, there are still people that need help.” 


“The world is getting scarier and these situations are getting more common. They need to start communicating with people and getting them exactly what they need personally.” said Emma. 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page